Advertisement

The Crummey Trust is named after D. Clifford Crummey, the first taxpayer to use this kind of trust successfully. Crummey Trusts may be used for gifts to beneficiaries of any age. Any time you give property to the trust, the beneficiary must have the right to withdraw the contribution during a brief window (typically 30 or 60 days). If the beneficiary does not withdraw the property, the gift becomes final and is locked in the trust until the trust terminates. The right to withdraw the contribution converts it into a present interest, thereby ensuring that the gift qualifies for the gift tax exclusion.

Advertisement

Benefits

The primary benefits of a Crummey Trust are as follows:

• The beneficiary has no right to receive the property at age 18 or 21, unlike 2503(c) Minor's Trusts or UGMA/UTMA accounts. The trust continues for as long as specified in the trust agreement.
• The trust can be established for multiple beneficiaries, including beneficiaries who have already reached age 21.
• Although the beneficiary has the right to withdraw any contribution, few beneficiaries will exercise this right because they know that the donor could stop giving future contributions.
• The maximum amount the beneficiary can withdraw is the annual contribution, not the entire trust.
• Once the beneficiary has waived his right to withdraw a particular contribution, control over the contribution rests with the trustee. The trustee has the right to make distributions from the trust for the benefit of the beneficiary.

Although the trust has a separate taxpayer identification number and files an annual tax return, the beneficiary must in most cases pay income tax on the trust's income.

Disadvantages

The disadvantages of these trusts are as follows:

• High setup and administration costs, due to the involvement of an attorney (e.g., drafting of the trust document). The annual waiver must be in writing.
• The trust is treated as an asset of the child for financial aid purposes (high impact).
• If the donor acts as a trustee, the trust will be included in the donor's gross taxable estate. It is best if the trustee is someone other than the donor or the donor's spouse.
• There is a chance that the beneficiary will not cooperate.

Additional Considerations

It is common for 2503(c) Minor's Trusts and Crummey Trusts to be combined into a hybrid trust that acts as a 2503(c) trust until age 21 and then converts to a Crummey Trust. This allows annual gifts to the trust to continue to qualify for the gift tax exclusion after the child reaches age 21.

Generally speaking, most parents will find that using the Uniform Gift/Transfer to Minor's Act meets their needs just as well as a 2503(c) Minor's Trust or a Crummey Trust. Note that all three types of trusts are treated as the child's asset for financial aid purposes, and so have a high impact on need-based financial aid eligibility. In most cases the parents would be better off establishing section 529 plans for their children.