For the purpose of changing the designated beneficiary, a "Member of
the Family" includes the following:
- children and grandchildren of the old beneficiary and their descendants,
- the step-children of the old beneficiary (but not their descendants),
- the siblings and step-siblings of the old beneficiary (including
brother, sister, stepbrother and stepsister),
- the parents and grandparents of the old beneficiary and their ancestors,
- the stepfather and stepmother of the old beneficiary (but not their parents),
- the nieces and nephews of the old beneficiary (son or daughter of
a brother or sister, but not of stepbrother or stepsister),
- the aunts and uncles of the old beneficiary (brother or sister of
the father or mother, but not of stepmother or stepfather),
- the in-laws of the old beneficiary (son-in-law, daughter-in-law,
father-in-law, mother-in-law, brother-in-law and sister-in-law),
- the spouse of any individual listed above,
- the first cousins of the old beneficiary, and
- the spouse of the old beneficiary.
If the new beneficiary is not a family member, the change of
beneficiary is treated as a taxable distribution to the account owner.
The account owner will then owe income taxes and a 10% tax penalty on
any earnings included in the transfer.
If you change the beneficiary to a generation below the generation of
the old beneficiary, there may be tax implications.
Advantages
The advantages common to section 529 prepaid tuition plans and section
529 college savings plans are as follows:
- The account owner controls access to funds. If the beneficiary
doesn't go to college, the account owner can get his or her
money back (with income taxes and a 10% penalty owed on earnings)
or change the beneficiary to another family member. This is unlike an
UGMA or UTMA account, where the child
assumes control upon reaching the age of majority and can spend
the money on anything they want.
- Both types of 529 plans offer tax-deferred growth and tax-free
withdrawals. The savings and accumulated earnings are exempt
from federal income tax if the distributions are used for
qualified higher education expenses.
- There may also be state income tax benefits for the state's plan,
such as qualified withdrawals being tax exempt (most states) and
full or partial state income tax deductions for contributions
(half the states).
- The assets in a section 529 plan are not considered part of the
account owner's taxable estate and are transferred immediately out
of the donor's estate. (If you take advantage of accelerated
giving and die within five years, a portion of the contribution
will be included in your gross estate.)
- Because contributions to a 529 plan are considered a present
interest, contributions of up to $13,000 per beneficiary ($26,000 from
a married couple using gift-splitting) are exempt from gift taxes.
- The accelerated gifting option allows one to contribute up to
$60,000 per beneficiary and average the contribution over a
five year period to avoid gift taxes. Married couples can
contribute up to $130,000 per beneficiary through gift splitting.
If you contribute more than these limits, you can use the unified
credit to offset the gift tax.
- The gift tax provisions makes section 529 plans a great estate
planning tool for wealthy families who want to minimize estate tax
liabilities.
- Section 529 plans provide a great opportunity for grandparents
to contribute to the education of their grandchildren.
- The account owner can choose any initial beneficiary.
- The account owner can change the beneficiary at any time, provided
that the new beneficiary is a member of the family of the old
beneficiary.
- The account owner can rollover funds to a different 529 plan or change
investment strategies once a year.
- The account owner can use money in US Savings Bonds (Series EE
since 12/31/1989 and Series I) and in Coverdell Education Savings
Accounts to fund a 529 plan without incurring income tax.
- No income phaseouts on contributions or withdrawals.
- 529 plans are managed by experienced investment companies, such as
Vanguard, Fidelity and TIAA-CREF.
- You can contribute to both a 529 plan and a Coverdell Education
Savings Account in the same year for the same beneficiary.
- You can still take advantage of other education tax benefits, such as
the Hope Scholarship and Lifetime Learning tax credits and
Coverdell Education Savings Accounts so long as different
qualified education expenses provide the basis for each program.
- The minimum investment amount is often much lower than that
required by most mutual funds, making section 529 plans more
accessible and affordable for lower income families.
- The plans also offer simplicity, by limiting the available
investment choices. As such, they may appeal to parents who do not
have the time or knowledge to manage their own investments.
- Disciplined saving. Section 529 plans typically require parents to
begin contributing on a regular schedule years before their children
matriculate in college. By requiring consistent and systematic
payments at regular intervals, section 529 plans get parents to start
saving and investing for college sooner. Many plans include features
that make it easy to set aside money regularly, such as payroll
deduction and automatic transfers from a checking or savings account.
- Most section 529 plans also offer lump sum investments, which may
be useful in other circumstances, such as divorce settlements and
probate of a will.
The advantages of section 529 college savings plans are as follows:
- Low impact on financial aid eligibility, because section 529
college savings plans are considered assets of the account
owner and not the beneficiary.
- Very high cumulative contribution limits, typically around $235,000
per beneficiary and as high as $305,000 per beneficiary.
- No restrictions on choice of college, other than that it must be
an accredited post-secondary institution.
- Flexible investment options, such as age-based asset allocation
strategies and risk-based asset allocation strategies.
Many offer a choice of professionally managed funds and index
funds.
- Can enroll at any time.
- No date by which funds must be used.
The advantages of section 529 prepaid tuition plans are as follows:
- Low impact on financial aid eligibility, because prepaid tuition plans
are considered assets of the account owner and not the beneficiary.
- Peace of mind. Parents who invest in a prepaid tuition plan
know that it will keep pace with the faster-than-inflation
increases in college tuition, letting them lock in future
tuition rates at today's prices.
- Most state prepaid tuition plans are guaranteed by the full faith and
credit of the state.
- The return on a prepaid tuition plan is often superior to the
typical return on a bank savings account or certificate of deposit.
(The one exception to this is the
CollegeSure CD from College
Savings Bank, which is similar in many ways to prepaid tuition
plans.
- Low risk. Many parents have a low tolerance for risks to
principal in their college savings accounts, so the low risk of
prepaid tuition plans is very attractive.
Some states allow you to contribute funds by charging
it to a credit card. If you're the type of person who pays off your
balance in full each month, and your credit card offers rewards for
charges (e.g., Discover Card's cash back, Citibank's Driver's Edge),
you may be able to get additional rewards for your contribution.
Prepaid tuition plans are often popular in divorce cases because
they allow each parent to pay a specified percentage of college costs
and because the parents can use a lump sum contribution to discharge
their obligation.
The advantages of saving through a section 529 plan increases with
increases in the family's income tax bracket, with the availability of
state income tax deductions for contributions, with the amount of
money invested, the amount of time available for the investment to
grow, and the size of the fees and sales charges.
This means that higher income families who can invest more, and
families who start saving sooner, will obtain the greatest benefit
from section 529 plans. Lower income families who are not able to save
as much will find that the annual maintenance and minimum balance fees
can erode a greater percentage of their returns. But families at every
income level should pay attention to the fees, because even a
difference in fees of just 0.5% can have a big impact on returns.
Disadvantages
The disadvantages common to section 529 prepaid tuition plans and section
529 college savings plans are as follows:
- The earnings portion of non-qualified withdrawals is taxed as
ordinary income at the account owner's rates, plus a 10% tax
penalty. If the beneficiary dies, becomes totally and permanently
disabled, the 10% tax penalty is waived. If the beneficiary receives a
scholarship, the 10% tax penalty is waived on distributions up to the
amount of the scholarship. States may also assess their own penalties
in addition to income tax on the earnings portion of the distribution.
- Section 529 plan accounts are not necessarily protected from
creditors of the account owner or beneficiary. Such protections vary
from state to state. For example, Medicaid might be able to use the
funds if the account owner needs nursing home care and
has no other funds available.
- Both types of plans have been around for just a few years, so it
is difficult to evaluate their long-term investment performance.
- Less disclosure is required for the managers of section 529 plans
than for other types of investments.
- Many families find it difficult to find the money to fund a
section 529 plan.
The disadvantages of section 529 college savings plans are as follows:
- State tax benefits may be limited to the state's own section 529
college savings plan.
- You are limited to the investment options provided by the plan.
- Although the more aggressive investment options offer a greater
potential return, they also offer a greater potential risk. Except for
principal protection portfolios like money market accounts and
guaranteed investments (offered by a few states), the principal you
invest is at risk. If the program's manager makes bad investment
decisions or the stock market declines, you could lose money.
- Expenses and sales charges may be higher than what you'd pay if
you invested the money yourself. Some plans charge excessively high
sales loads of as much as 5% or 6% and management fees of as much as
2% a year.
The disadvantages of section 529 prepaid tuition plans are as follows:
- Prepaid tuition plans may offer a return on investment that is not
as good as other investments. A family with financial savvy might
be better off investing the funds on their own through a section
529 college savings plan.
- Your investment in a prepaid tuition plan may not meet the full
cost of private or out-of-state colleges. In most states the
plans are geared toward in-state public colleges.
- The enrollment period may be limited.
- There may be penalties and/or reductions in investment returns for
non-qualified withdrawals or account cancellation.
- Many state prepaid tuition plans are limited to tuition and fees,
and do not include savings for room and board. So the family may
need to plan separately for these additional costs.
- In many states the account owner or the beneficiary must be a
state resident when the account is opened.
- Maximum contributions are much lower than for section 529 college
savings plans.
- Many prepaid tuition plans include a 10-year time limit from the
date of expected college entrance or high school
graduation. Another less common limit is a requirement that the
funds be used by the time the beneficiary reaches age 30.
Eligible Schools
A database of all
eligible schools
can be found on the US Department
of Education web site. You can also call the US Department of
Education at 1-800-872-5987.
For tuition rates at US colleges and universities, visit the
IPEDS COOL tuition finder.
Sunsetting
The Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001 (EGTRRA)
made several improvements to qualified tuition programs in section
402. These improvements were set to expire on December 31,
2010. However, Section 1304 in Title XIII of the Pension Protection
Act of 2006 (P.L. 109-280) eliminated the sunset. This means that the
following provisions relating to section 529 plans are now permanent:
- Federal tax-free distributions if the withdrawal was used for
qualified higher education expenses. (Before EGTRRA-2001, section
529 plans grew in a tax-deferred fashion, and the earnings portion of
withdrawals were taxed as ordinary income at the rate of the
beneficiary.)
- Tax-free rollovers to another section 529 plan once per
twelve-month period without requiring a change of beneficiary.
- During a change of beneficiary, the new beneficiary may be a first
cousin of the old beneficiary.
- Educational institutions may establish their own prepaid tuition
plans starting in 2004.
- Qualifying expenses include certain additional expenses for
special needs beneficiaries.
- Non-qualified distributions are subject to a 10% tax penalty.
- Allowed one to use a section 529 plan, Coverdell Education Savings
Account, Hope Scholarship and Lifetime Learning tax credit in the
same year, so long as different qualifying expenses were used as
the basis for each program.
- Allowed contributions to both section 529 plans
and the Coverdell Education Savings Accounts for the same
beneficiary in the same year.
- The cap on room and board for students living off campus (but not
at home) were increased from $2,500 to the amounts as published in
the school's cost of attendance student budget.
More Information
For more information about section 529 plans and other education tax
benefits, please see
IRS Publication 970,
Tax Benefits for Higher Education.
There are also a variety of
professional resources
that will be of interest primarily to state government administrators,
financial aid professionals and public policy analysts.