![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
Return to Professional Judgment |
Trust Funds and Custodial Accounts
Trust funds are ineffective at sheltering money from the need analysis process.
Even worse, restrictions on access to the principal may keep the trust
fund around throughout the student's postsecondary education, hurting
the student's eligibility for need-based financial aid every year.
When parents discover the negative consequences, they often ask for a
professional judgment review.
Similar issues arise when parents conscientiously set up a custodial
account (UGMA/UTMA account) in the child's name to save for college,
not realizing the negative impact on financial aid eligibility.
In both cases they ask for the asset to be disregarded or treated as a
parent asset. A widow or widower might also ask for an asset to be
disregarded if it represents the proceeds of a life insurance policy
on the deceased spouse.
Voluntary restrictions on access to principal are insufficient grounds
to justify disregarding an asset. Section 480(f) of the Higher
Education Act clearly indicates that trusts are considered assets. It
also indicates that time deposits and tax shelters are considered
assets.
The only situations in which a trust fund can be disregarded are:
A few financial aid administrators will use professional judgment to
disregard a trust fund with voluntary restrictions when there are
special circumstances relating to those restrictions. For example, if
there is a trust established to pay for future medical expenses of a
child with a serious illness, the financial aid administrator might
decide to eliminate it as an asset even if the trust was not
established by court order. Similarly, if the proceeds of a life
insurance policy were placed in an annuity held by a trust to pay for
future living expenses of the surviving spouse, the financial aid
administrator might decide to disregard the value of the trust as an
asset, but count the current year's payments from the trust as
income. In both cases it is important that the restrictions on the
trust be irrevocable. Otherwise, the family can use the trust for any
purpose whatsoever. In addition, it is never appropriate to use
professional judgment to disregard
a trust when the trust was not established in connection with a
special circumstance. In particular, Section 2503(c) Minor's Trusts,
Crummey Trusts, and variations on these trusts may not be
disregarded. It is not possible to circumvent need analysis simply by
putting money in a trust fund.
Some parents will ask financial aid administrators to treat a
custodial account or trust fund as though it were a parent asset, on
the grounds that the money originally came from the parent. This is
insufficient grounds for a professional judgment decision, as there is
no special circumstance to justify it. Errors in financial planning do
not constitute special circumstances.
It is important to assign the correct value to the trust. When both
the principal and income derived from the trust belong to the same
person, the value is simply the current value of the assets held by
the trust. When the family owns only the income from the trust, one
must calculate the net present value of the future income stream. It
is not correct to multiply the annual income by the number of years of
income, as this fails to consider that future payments are worth less
in current dollars than their face value. Instead, the value is the
present cost of an annuity that would generate the same income stream.
FinAid's
Net Present Value calculator
may also be used to calculate the current value of such a trust.
The bank that manages the trust might also be able to provide a net
present value for the trust. One could also call a factoring company
(a company that buys future income streams, such as lottery prizes and
insurance settlements) to see what value they would assign to the trust.
If the trust has several beneficiaries, but the distributions from the
trust are at the discretion of the trustee and are not required to be
distributed equally, the financial aid administrator may nevertheless
assume that the trust's value is split equally. Only when the trust
document or the trustee has specified a particular percentage
distribution does that override the default assumption of an equal
distribution.
Financial aid administrators should always ask for a copy of the trust
document before making a decision to exclude all or part of a trust as
an asset or before assigning a value to a trust.
Additional information may be found in FinAid's section concerning
Trust Funds and Financial Aid.
|
| Home | Loans | Scholarships | Savings | Military Aid | Other Types of Aid | Financial Aid Applications Answering Your Questions | Calculators | Beyond Financial Aid | Site Map | About FinAid® |
| Copyright © 2013 by FinAid Page, LLC. All rights reserved. Mark Kantrowitz, Publisher www.FinAid.org |